Chewy vs Petco vs Amazon Pets: Which Has Better Cashback?
Not sure which pet retailer gives you the best deal? We've done the math for you. Here's a complete side-by-side comparison of the three biggest pet supply retailers.
Winner: Chewy — Best cashback (4%), best customer service, best AutoShip program
Runner-up: Amazon Pets — Best for Prime members who want convenience
Third: Petco — Best for in-store pickup and pet services
Runner-up: Amazon Pets — Best for Prime members who want convenience
Third: Petco — Best for in-store pickup and pet services
Side-by-Side Comparison
💰 Cashback Rate
Chewy: 4% 🏆
Amazon Pets: 2.5%
Petco: 3%
Chewy: 4% 🏆
Amazon Pets: 2.5%
Petco: 3%
📦 Shipping
Chewy: Free over $49 (1-3 days) 🏆
Amazon Pets: Free with Prime (2 days)
Petco: Free over $35 or in-store pickup
Chewy: Free over $49 (1-3 days) 🏆
Amazon Pets: Free with Prime (2 days)
Petco: Free over $35 or in-store pickup
🔄 Subscription Discount
Chewy: 5-10% AutoShip 🏆
Amazon Pets: 5-15% Subscribe & Save
Petco: 5% repeat delivery
Chewy: 5-10% AutoShip 🏆
Amazon Pets: 5-15% Subscribe & Save
Petco: 5% repeat delivery
🏪 Store Network
Chewy: Online only
Petco: 1,500+ stores 🏆
Amazon Pets: Online only (with Amazon returns)
Chewy: Online only
Petco: 1,500+ stores 🏆
Amazon Pets: Online only (with Amazon returns)
When to Choose Each Store
Choose Chewy when...
- Ordering regular pet food and supplies
- You want the highest cashback (4%)
- You need reliable AutoShip delivery
- You value exceptional customer service
Choose Amazon Pets when...
- You're already a Prime member
- You want Subscribe & Save (5-15% off)
- You need the widest product selection
- You want Amazon's return policy
Choose Petco when...
- You need supplies the same day (in-store)
- You use Petco grooming or vet services
- You have aquarium or reptile needs
- You want in-store pickup options
Our Recommendation
For most pet owners, Chewy is the best all-around choice. It offers the highest cashback (4%), the best AutoShip program, and legendary customer service. Use Amazon Pets as a backup for Prime-exclusive deals, and Petco when you need something immediately from a physical store.